What are the Best File Formats to Export from SOLIDWORKS?

HOW DO I EXPORT DIFFERENT FILE TYPES FROM SOLIDWORKS?

The first thing to consider when collaborating with other users on a project is which CAD software they are using.

If they are using the same version of SOLIDWORKS as you, then no export is required, other than the occasional Pack & Go.

You can collaborate online through the SOLIDWORKS Cloud Services, or send part files and zipped folders of assemblies and drawings through with the Pack and Go command.

Since SOLIDWORKS 2024, you can also save files as previous versions for opening in SOLIDWORKS 2022 or 2023.

Sometimes it isn’t appropriate to send your SOLIDWORKS files. One reason not to send a SOLIDWORKS file to a collaborator would be to disguise intellectual property.

In this case, exporting as a neutral file format will prevent the feature tree and design intent of the model from being revealed.

Models can also be further simplified by removing internal geometry with the defeature command that we’ll explore later in this blog.

You can learn how to Pack & Go files from SOLIDWORKS with this short tutorial.

IS THERE A PREFERRED FILE TYPE TO IMPORT INTO SOLIDWORKS?

If you must import or export CAD files between different programs, then native file formats will always be preferred over neutral ones.

With the 3D Interconnect import option turned on, SOLIDWORKS can directly import files from Catia V5, Autodesk Inventor, and more, while retaining a link to the original file and preserving data during translation.

Each CAD package uses different algorithms to represent 3D shapes. When these files are translated, there will always be an opportunity for error to occur due to tolerance and rounding differences.

When importing a native file this translation only occurs once, leading to fewer opportunities for error.

However, if you were to export a SOLIDWORKS file into a neutral file format (such as STEP) and then reimport it into a different CAD system, two data translations will have occurred, increasing the likelihood of geometric errors.

If you receive a neutral format CAD file, it is worthwhile asking how many times the file has potentially been translated between systems.

If the answer is unknown, we recommend re-exporting the file from the original native CAD, to reduce the stack up of tolerances and potential for errors.

WHICH NEUTRAL FILE FORMAT SHOULD I USE?

Our recommended order of priority for neutral file formats starts with Parasolid, then ACIS, STEP and finally IGES.

Other neutral file formats do exist, such as STL and OBJ, but these will import as graphical bodies which are typically hard to work with.

Parasolids are ideal because this format shares the same underlying modelling kernel as SOLIDWORKS. The kernel information does not need to be translated, which results in better model accuracy.

Beyond Parasolid, our next best choices would be ACIS, STEP and IGES - in that order. Each of these file formats requires greater translation than the next, increasing the risk of geometry errors.

We recommend that you always ask the recipient of the neutral file which type of files they can import, and use this information to choose the best option from the above format hierarchy.

HOW CAN I SHARE CAD DATA AND PROTECT INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY?

As part of the TriMech Group, we help businesses across the world collaborate, design, and manufacture products while protecting their intellectual property (IP).

It’s important to remember that sharing SOLIDWORKS files gives the recipient access to all of the modelling data that is included within the part, drawing, assembly, or Pack and Go.

If you are sharing SOLIDWORKS files, then consider whether the recipient requires all of the CAD data.

You could share an interactive (but still protected) version of your CAD via a link through the Share & Markup function included with the SOLIDWORKS Cloud Services, or save a version of your CAD to view with the free eDrawings CAD viewer.

To protect IP, you can export files as non-SOLIDWORKS files. This removes the feature tree data, as each CAD package has different ways of creating and organizing model features.

You can test this by exporting a file and re-importing it to observe what information is stored in the neutral file before you send it.

If you need to take this a step further, and obscure, remove, or simplify details of the model, then the defeature command can be used.

This allows you to create an independent copy of your model and customise what model components and features you would like to share with collaborators.

This could include removing internal components or features that a collaborator does not need to see.